California

1. Summary
Male voters in California defeated an equal suffrage measure in 1896 but approved women voting after a rousing campaign in 1911. The legislature ratified the 19th Amendment on November 1, 1919. Acknowledgement.
2. State Suffrage History
History of Women’s Suffrage in California
By Elizabeth Aguayo, California State Archives
The enfranchisement of women, both in California and the United States, was a long and challenging endeavor that spanned nearly 100 years. The women’s suffrage movement changed the way our democracy works and ratified the rights and responsibilities of citizenship for women including the right to vote.
In July 1871, a forty-four-year-old widow by the name of Ellen R. Van Valkenburg, sued Santa Cruz County Clerk Albert Brown after he refused to include her name in the county’s Great Register of voters. The essence of her argument was that under the 14th Amendment of the US Constitution, many American women like herself were granted citizenship, and therefore, the rights of citizenship which included voting. Disappointed by the California’s Third District Court, which ruled against her, Van Valkenburg decided to appeal. The following January, the Supreme Court of California supported the lower court’s verdict denying her and other women alike representation and the right to vote.
Petitions were circulated around the state for signatures in 1879 in an effort to amend Article II of the 1849 constitution which granted “every white male” in the state, the right to vote. The petition declaring that “no citizen of the State shall be disenfranchised on account of sex” received over 2,500 signatures in total. Nonetheless, hopes for modifying the constitution at the 1879 Constitutional Convention were dismissed. Various opponents within the all-male delegate body expressed their fears of women participating in politics and repealed the amendment.
The first attempt for women’s suffrage in California failed in the 1896 general election. This eight-month active campaign faced many challenges including financial problems. Nonetheless, women persisted, kept organizing and continued fighting for their right to vote in the following years. In 1910, women seized the opportunity of Governor James Norris Gillett’s new administration and persuaded the California state legislature to add the question, “Should women be allowed to vote?” on the 1911 ballot.
Supporters had only eight months to organize their campaign to win voter approval for this proposal. As the general attitude of the public toward women voting was more “amused, indifferent and incredulous” than hostile, wrote suffrage leader Louise Wall, “it seemed best for us to put forth positive arguments of a hopeful, constructive sort rather than arguments that ended in criticism or irony.”
Elizabeth Lowe Watson, a former pastor, led the California Equal Suffrage Association in northern California. The less populated south was covered by two organizations, the Political Equality League founded by Pasadena businessman John Hyde Braly, and the Votes for Women Club led by attorney Clara Shortridge Foltz. These and other groups mobilized over 10,000 local supporters – teachers, college women, wage earners and veteran suffragists – to carry out the vast statewide drive.
To publicize their Cause as widely as possible, suffragists produced pin-back buttons, pennants and posters. They created postcards, playing cards and shopping bags. They used electric signs, 8-foot tall billboards and lantern slides at night to flash their message. They distributed over three million pieces of literature and over 90,000 “Votes for Women” buttons in Southern California alone.
Learning from earlier elections, suffrage leaders anticipated strong opposition by saloon and business interests in the cities who feared prohibition so they concentrated their forces on the rural districts. Speakers, organizers, automobile tours and press material were sent to reach distant voters in the remote corners of the great state. Women in every county organized clubs and associations to win the support of prominent men, newspaper editors, business and clergymen as well as individual voters.
On Election Day, October 10, 1911, the measure was soundly defeated in the San Francisco Bay Area and just barely passed in Los Angeles. Disheartened and disappointed, suffragists began to plan yet another campaign when late reports from the rural counties began to swing the vote in their favor.
When the long count was finally completed several days later, Equal Suffrage had passed by only 3,587 votes – an average majority of one vote in each precinct in the state. The final count was 125,037 to 121,450, making California the 6th state in the nation to give women the right to vote.
The right to vote in California not only allowed women to participate in the democratic process, but also led to women being elected into office. In 1918, Grace S. Dorris, Esto B. Broughton, Anna L. Saylor, and Elizabeth Hughes were the first four women to be elected to the California State Assembly; these women were among the first to hold distinguishable roles in state government advocating for women’s rights.
California’s women’s suffrage campaign inspired other states to join the movement. Nearly a decade after women won the right to vote in California, women were granted this right in all states at the federal level with the passage and ratification of the 19th Amendment to the US Constitution on August 26, 1920. Today, this day is known as Women’s Equality Day. Suffragists Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony played pivotal roles in this movement successfully giving female voters the right to a ballot.
Though it has been nearly 100 years since women won the right to vote, the effort to increase female representation, both in numbers and in ethnic diversity, is a journey that will continue to exist both at the state and national level. As of 2019, approximately 31% of the California State Legislature is female. According to figures from the National Conference of State Legislatures, women made up 25.4% of all state legislators in 2018. With the help of prominent civil rights activists, Rosa Parks, Dolores Huerta, and new activists and leaders, the work of reaching equality in representation continues.
History of Women’s Suffrage in California,
By Elizabeth Aguayo, California State Archives
https://www.sos.ca.gov/archives/women-get-right-vote/history-womens-suffrage-california
[Permission to reproduce the article above has been granted.]
3. State Suffragists
Naomi Talbert Anderson
Ella Bradford Copeland Allen, San Diego: Actively involved in the San Diego Equal Suffrage Association, she served as the corresponding secretary. They presented their views about the importance of women’s suffrage and distributed literature.
Dr. Charlotte Baker, San Diego, 1855 – 1937: Charlotte served as president of the San Diego Equal Suffrage Association in 1911; she and her cadre of suffragists urged men throughout the county to vote for women’s right to vote, an initiative on the October 10 California ballot. After its passage, Charlotte contacted San Diegan women to register to vote in preparation for an election in November 1911.
Harriet A. Whitcher Ballou, San Diego: Suffrage worker.
John Hyde Braly
Lillian Harris Coffin
Sara Bard Field (Cincinnati)
Clara Shortridge Foltz, San Diego, 1849 – 1934: the first woman attorney in California—without attending law school after being denied admission to Hastings School of Law. In 1911, Clara’s Women’s Vote Amendment passed successfully and granted women the right to vote in California. Clara founded the Votes for Women Club and served as its president.
Laura DeForce Gordon
Mary Simons Gibson
Lydia Harris, San Diego: Suffrage worker.
Phoebe Hearst, San Francisco: First Vice Chairman, NWP. Made significant financial contributions to NWP.
Lydia Knapp Horton, San Diego, 1843 – 1926: She was actively involved in the Woman’s Suffrage Society and the women’s club movement.
Lydia Flood Jackson, Oakland: entrepreneur and suffragist.
Mary McHenry Keith
Elizabeth Thacher Kent, Kentfield: Executive Committee of Congressional Union in 1914 and of NWP 1916.
Flora Kimball, San Diego, 1829 – 1898: a writer, community activist, suffragist, and lay horticulturist; served as president of the Women’s Suffrage Club.
Beatrice Kinkead, Mountain View: Picketed White House in 1917, arrested, tried, sentenced, and incarcerated.
Mary T. Longley
Alice (Moore) McComas, Los Angeles: Held numerous offices in Women’s Suffrage Association of Los Angeles. She organized the first county suffrage convention in California.
Mrs. George Norton, San Diego: Suffrage worker.
Eleanor Partridge, San Diego: Suffrage worker.
Vivian Pierce, San Diego: traveled to Washington, D.C. to participate in the suffrage movement at the national level.
Emily Pitts-Stevens
John E. Raker
Dr. Mary Bennett Ritter, San Diego, 1860 – 1949: Her philanthropic interests included women’s suffrage, clean water and sanitation, and science education.
Aaron A. Sargent, Nevada City: At the request of Susan B. Anthony, he introduced to congress the suffrage amendment (also known as the Susan B. Anthony Amendment) in 1878.
Ellen Clark Sargent, Nevada City: Leading voting rights advocate.
Mrs. Seward A. Simons
Annie Kimball Sloane, San Diego: Suffrage worker.
Selina Solomons
Elmira T. Stephens
Marietta L. Stow
Helen Todd
Florence Watson Toll, San Diego: For the 1910 election campaign, Florence served as the vice president of the San Diego Equal Suffrage Association and presented the campaign strategy: “Every house is to be invaded. Every man whose name appears on the register will be interviewed by a committee of women. Of course, if we find out a man isn’t with us, we intend to keep right on after him until he is convinced.”
Louis Herrick Wall
Elizabeth Lowe Watson
Charlotte Le Moyne Wills
Maud Younger, San Francisco: Younger’s wealthy background enabled her to act as an important bridge between different groups of women (labor unions) in the victorious suffrage campaign in 1911. Went to Washington DC to work with the NWP.
4. Additional Resources
Books
The Sixth Star: Images and Memorabilia of California Women’s Political History 1868-1915 by Mae Silver and Sue Cazaly, 2000
How We Won the Vote in California, A True Story of the Campaign of 1911 by Selina Solomons, (The New Woman Publishing Co.), from the Claremont College Library
Class Conflict and Class Coalition in the California Woman Suffrage Movement, 1907-1912: The San Francisco Wage Earners’ Suffrage League by Susan Englander, 1992
Becoming Citizens: The Emergence and Development of the California Women’s Movement, 1880-1911 by Gayle Gullett, 2000
Remarkable Women of California by Marilyn Brant Chandler DeYoung, 2015
Winning Equal Suffrage in California: Reports of Committees of the College Equal Suffrage League of Northern California by College Equal Suffrage League of Northern California, 1913 [reprint]
More than Petticoats: Remarkable California Women by Erin H. Turner, 2014
California Women Win the Vote 1911. Nine years before the Federal Amendment. Written, Produced and Directed by Martha Wheelock (film)
Articles
“Women Claim the Vote in California” by Mae Silver https://www.foundsf.org/index.php?title=WOMEN_CLAIM_THE_VOTE_IN_CALIFORNIA
“Winning California for Woman Suffrage, 1911” by Robert P. J. Cooney, Jr. http://www.americangraphicpress.com/articlesphotographs.html
“Women Suffrage, Progressive Era: 1890–1920s,” Oakland Museum of California
http://picturethis.museumca.org/timeline/progressive-era-1890-1920s/women-suffrage/info
Websites
California Woman Suffrage 1870-1911, http://exhibitions.globalfundforwomen.org/exhibitions/california-suffrage
California Women and the Vote, A Centennial Celebration, https://bancroft.berkeley.edu/Exhibits/suffrage/index.html
California 2020 Women’s Suffrage Project, https://cawomenssuffrageproject.org/
Long Beach Suffrage 100, https://lbsuffrage100.com/
