Arkansas

Arkansas State Flag

1. Summary

Voters never had a say on women’s suffrage but the legislature passed Primary Suffrage in 1917, which was a major step forward in the South. Women’s suffrage was defeated in 1919 but the 19th Amendment was ratified on July 28, 1919. Acknowledgement.

2a. State Suffrage History

2a. State Suffrage History

Women’s Suffrage in Arkansas: A Brief History

By Jeannie Whayne, The Arkansas Women’s Suffrage Centennial Project

Suffrage in Arkansas was achieved after a long struggle to secure the ballot, but it began in the homes and churches of ordinary women in the antebellum era who were far from the public sphere and had only an inkling of the possibilities that might someday be open to them. They acquiesced in their dependence on their husbands, accepting the legal liability of coverture and sometimes paid the price when their menfolk turned out to be profligate.

One of the chief attributes of the patriarchy was the economic dependence of married women who had no right to the property they brought into the marriage. Indeed, upon taking vows, they surrendered their economic independence and their husbands assumed the right to their estates. The notion that women were weak and dependent was thus codified in law, but it was also justified in the ideology of separate spheres. Women like Matilda Fulton, the wife of one of the state’s first senators, adhered to the idea of separate spheres for men and women, even as she literally ran their plantation while her husband was away in Washington, D.C. At nine months pregnant she oversaw the slaughtering of hogs, but both Matilda and her politician husband ignored the reality of her competence and adopted the language of female inferiority. Time and again, however, women like Matilda demonstrated their capabilities and quietly challenged the notion of male superiority.

Even in antebellum Arkansas, women ventured out of the household and into the so-called male-sphere by engaging in church activities beyond those having to do with worship. Women, in fact, found not only spiritual sustenance but emotional and psychological support from other women. Their early organizations focused on assisting the destitute among their co-congregants but in some cases their activities extended into their communities and beyond.

A few women became involved in early suffrage efforts but most Arkansas women, particularly those in isolated rural areas, focused on every day issues affecting their families and their neighbors. As the antebellum era gave way to the Civil War, however, women were called upon to do more than ever to run their households and assume the duties typically assigned to their husbands. Town and city women were especially affected by the realization of their competence and though they surrendered their economic authority in the post-war era, some of them retained a greater sense of their own importance and supported a movement for women’s suffrage.
Miles Ledford Langley, a legislator from Arkadelphia, proposed a women’s suffrage plank at the Constitutional Convention of 1868, arguing that women were created equal to men and deserved the right to vote. This gratified many Arkansas women, but some of Langley’s fellow male legislators openly and condescendingly scoffed at the idea and the measure went down to defeat.
No viable women’s suffrage organization arose in the wake of the 1868 defeat, but women began to organize in other ways and, in doing so, honed their skills and paved the way for future women’s suffrage advocates. The most important single organization that instructed women on organizational activities was the Women’s Christian Temperance Union (WCTU), which was originally organized in Ohio in 1873. It spread rapidly and by the 1880s, Arkansas women had organized WCTU chapters across the state.

Rather than advocate for an out-right ban on alcohol, the WCTU focused on convincing officials to pass local option ordinances that had to be approved by voters. Any community that passed such an ordinance could refuse to issue licenses to individuals who wanted to open saloons. Women in the WCTU argued that since intoxicated men made poor husbands, they were merely extending their duties as the caregivers of the home – the sphere assigned to women – to the political realm even though they themselves could not vote. With the election of Francis Willard as the national WCTU president in 1879, the organization extended its activities beyond its original cause and even began to advocate for women’s suffrage. By the 1880s, women’s suffrage organizations in Arkansas again emerged. One was founded by Clara McDiarmid, who was herself a lawyer and an officer in the WCTU, in 1888. She became a leader in the struggle for woman suffrage in the state.

Two women’s journals founded in Arkansas in the 1880s provided women with opportunities to learn about issues important to them. Although the Arkansas Ladies Journal, founded by Mary W. Loughborough, was not dedicated solely to the issue of women’s suffrage, it supported the cause with enthusiasm. In 1888, three other women, Catherine “Kate” Campbell Cunningham, Mrs. Mary Burt Brooks, and Mrs. William Cohoon, began publishing the Woman’s Chronicle, which became the chief organ for women’s suffrage in the South. Unfortunately, in ceased publication in 1899 after Cunningham’s death.
Despite the episodic nature of their organizations and journals, Arkansas women continued to host suffrage society meetings and speak out on the issue throughout the 1890s. Small auxiliary societies periodically sprang up in towns throughout the state, but most of them were short lived. Forrest City, Lonoke, Clarksville, Beebe, and Judsonia all had organizations for a while, and women from those towns as well as from Hot Springs, Fort Smith, Hazen, Hope, Malvern, Stuttgart, Ozark, and Rogers, attended suffrage conventions in Little Rock. Arkansas suffragettes were affiliated with Susan B. Anthony’s National American Woman Suffrage Association and filed annual reports with their organizations and sent delegates to national meetings. They largely rejected Alice Paul’s more radical National Woman’s Party.

Arkansas suffragettes had never been rabble-rousers. Rather, they were middle-class white women, and their suffrage movement became even more respectable in the early years of the progressive era. Women across Arkansas had been organizing book clubs and library societies since the 1870s. After the emergence of the progressive era, however, they began engaging more fully in the public arena. Although they continued to rationalize their participation in these clubs as part of an extension of women’s duty to women and families and schools and churches, many club women developed organizational skills and moved into the newly developing suffrage movement.

In 1911 the suffrage effort was revitalized and women began lobbying the legislature heavily. With the support of Governor Charles Brough and his wife Anne, they gained a significant victory in 1917 when Arkansas became the first non-suffrage state to allow women to vote in the Arkansas primary elections. They then began to work tirelessly for a suffrage amendment to the state constitution and were successful in placing such a measure on the 1920 ballot. However, before that election took place, the United States passed the federal woman suffrage amendment in 1919, and Arkansas suffragettes greeted its passage with optimism, believing that it would have no difficulty in being ratified in Arkansas. Arkansas subsequently became the 12th state to ratify the 19th Amendment. On March 17, 1920, as women moved from securing the ballot to exercising the vote, the first League of Women Voters chapters in the state were formed in little Rock.

Jeannie Whayne, The Arkansas Women’s Suffrage Centennial Project, https://ualrexhibits.org/suffrage/

[Permission to reproduce the article above has been granted.]

2b. State Suffrage History

2b. State Suffrage History

Women’s Suffrage Movement

By Paula Kyzer Taylor, Encyclopedia of Arkansas History & Culture

After the Civil War, Arkansas leaders began advocating women’s right to vote. Women’s suffrage clubs started to organize, and an Arkansas women’s suffrage movement emerged. These suffragist leaders lectured at meetings, campaigned on street corners, and lobbied the Arkansas legislature for a women’s suffrage law. This campaign ended in 1920 with the Nineteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution giving women the right to vote.
An Arkansas law proposing women’s suffrage was initially introduced by Miles Ledford Langley of Arkadelphia (Clark County), a representative to the Arkansas Constitutional Convention of 1868. On February 11, 1868, the Arkansas Gazette reported that he made a motion that “all citizens 21 years of age, who can read and write the English language, shall be eligible to the elective franchise and entitled to equal political rights and privileges.” The next day, he delivered an address to the Arkansas House of Representatives on the need for women’s suffrage. “Mr. Langley spoke earnestly but his remarks elicited much laughter,” reported the Arkansas Gazette on February 15. Langley wrote to Susan B. Anthony on March 5 and apologized that the 1868 Arkansas Constitution did not give a “guarantee to woman her God-given and well-earned rights of civil and political equality.”

Articles on “Women’s Rights” soon began to appear in the Arkansas Gazette. On December 31, 1869, the paper printed an invitation to Phoebe Couzins, a suffragist, to speak in Little Rock (Pulaski County) on women’s suffrage. Couzins, a lawyer from Missouri, spoke on the need for influential women in politics, as reported in the Arkansas Gazette on January 5, 1870. Arkansas suffragists turned to national publications for support, and their letters appeared in the National Woman Suffrage Association (NWSA) newsletter, Woman’s Journal of Boston, Massachusetts.

On September 10, 1881, Lizzie Dorman Fyler reported to the Woman’s Journal that the Arkansas Woman Suffrage Association (AWSA) had been organized. Fyler was its president. A lawyer from Massachusetts, Fyler made her home in Eureka Springs (Carroll County). She reported to the Woman’s Journal on October 22, 1881, that the “Arkansas Woman Suffrage Association has been organized for the purpose of securing such legislation as shall secure to woman all the rights and privileges which belong to citizens in a free republic.” By October 9, 1885, she reported that the AWSA had disbanded. Fyler died on November 11, 1885.

In 1888, Clara McDiarmid, an officer in the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union (WCTU), organized the Arkansas Equal Suffrage Association (AESA) in Little Rock. McDiarmid was a native of Noblesville, Indiana, and a lawyer in Kansas City, Missouri. Unable to practice law in Arkansas, she used her law degree experience to counsel women on their legal rights. McDiarmid kept the AESA going by writing articles for the Little Rock women’s suffrage magazine, Woman’s Chronicle (which was founded by Kate Cunningham), and attended National Woman Suffrage Association meetings. She died on July 22, 1899, leaving the AESA without leadership. The suffragists soon dispersed.

By 1911, suffragists organized again. Seventy-five women met for the purpose of organizing the Political Equality League (PEL). Mary Fletcher, the youngest daughter of John Gould Fletcher Sr. and sister of the well-known suffragist Adolphine Fletcher Terry, was elected president. While the PEL sought “to secure equal suffrage,” its members were also “expected to take an interest in questions of legislative, municipal and home affairs.”

The PEL’s main concern was the proposed Arkansas constitutional amendment for women’s suffrage. Public hearings were held on March 15, 1911, with speakers such as Minnie U. Rutherford, “who made forceful appeals for the [women’s] right to vote.” The amendment passed in the Senate and went on to the House on April 12, 1911. State Representative George L. Grant spoke in favor of the resolution, stating that the enfranchisement of women was long overdue. The House opposition, however, came from the liquor interests, which held that women “should not be contaminated with politics” and that women belonged in the home.

The liquor industry was alarmed by the Woman’s Christian Temperance Union (WCTU). An active organization, the WCTU had supported temperance in Arkansas since 1879 and, since 1888, had viewed women’s suffrage as a way to achieve prohibition. Minnie Rutherford, Lizzie Dorman Fyler, and Clara McDiarmid were among many suffragists who were members of the WCTU. At the House hearing on the pending legislation for prohibition versus local option, WCTU representative Rutherford spoke on the benefits of a state-wide prohibition law. The women’s suffrage amendment of 1911 ultimately failed.

The Arkansas women’s suffrage movement gained momentum as women’s suffrage leagues spread from Little Rock to cities such as Hot Springs (Garland County), Pine Bluff (Jefferson County), Malvern (Hot Spring County), and Fayetteville (Washington County). In October 1914, a state convention in Little Rock officially organized the Arkansas Woman Suffrage Association (AWSA). The president, Alice Ellington, asked “all equal suffrage sympathizers for contributions to aid the fight to have a constitutional amendment submitted by the legislature.” In 1915, the Political Equality League joined with the Arkansas Federation of Women’s Clubs (AFWC), and at its convention, the AFWC advocated a women’s suffrage resolution. Once again, a women’s suffrage amendment was proposed for the Arkansas Constitution. Rutherford spoke to the hearing committee, and Florence Brown Cotnam addressed the House. This time, the amendment passed. However, four amendments were to be voted on, but according to state law, only three could go before the public. Therefore, the women’s suffrage amendment failed again.

In 1916, Alice Paul, president of the National Woman’s Party, visited Little Rock to organize a branch of the National Woman’s Party. Carrie Chapman Catt, president of the National American Woman Suffrage Association (NAWSA), also came to Arkansas to campaign for women’s suffrage. Altogether, women’s suffrage membership increased significantly, according to the October 17, 1916, Arkansas Democrat.

With the Arkansas women’s suffrage movement still growing in popularity, on February 7, 1917, state representative John A. Riggs of Hot Springs introduced in the Arkansas House a women’s primary suffrage bill. It allowed women to vote in primary elections. The Arkansas House voted favorably 71–19, and the Senate voted 17–15 in favor. Governor Charles Hillman Brough noted that he favored women’s enfranchisement and considered it an honor to sign the measure. Finally, a women’s suffrage bill passed and made Arkansas the “first non-suffrage state in the Union” to permit women to vote in primary elections.

This new responsibility caused the Arkansas women’s suffrage movement to modify its structure. In early 1917, the “Arkansas Woman Suffrage Association reorganized along Democratic Party ward and precinct lines to become the Arkansas Equal Suffrage Central Committee” (AESCC) with Alice Ellington as chairwoman. Reorganizing was essential to “teach women how to work with political parties.” In Little Rock, suffrage schools taught “methods of agitation.” When the United States entered World War I, suffragists joined in the war effort by selling Liberty Bonds, working for the Red Cross, and doing other jobs to help win the war.

In August 1917, Florence Brown Cotnam became chairwoman of the Equal Suffrage State Central Committee, and with influence by Carrie Chapman Catt, redirected the suffrage leagues to focus on the federal amendment to the U.S. Constitution. In November, the AESCC was joined by the Little Rock branch of the National Woman’s Party to campaign for a federal women’s suffrage amendment.

Statewide primaries were held in May 1918, and more than 40,000 women voted. As a result, over fifty female delegates were elected to the Democratic State Convention. The convention included a women’s suffrage plank in its platform, endorsed “unlimited suffrage for women,” and supported a federal women’s suffrage amendment. During 1918, another attempt was made to include women’s suffrage in a proposed Arkansas Constitution, but the constitution failed to receive a majority in the popular vote.

Governor Brough, in his 1919 (second term) inaugural address, endorsed a women’s suffrage amendment to the Arkansas Constitution, as well as the ratification of the federal women’s suffrage amendment. In June 1919, Congress passed the federal women’s suffrage amendment and submitted it to the states for its ratification. A special session was required for the Arkansas General Assembly to meet and to ratify the amendment. Cotnam and members of the AESCC started writing letters to legislators; many were enthusiastic and promised to be there and vote.

On July 28, 1919, Brough called a special session for the purpose of ratifying the Nineteenth Amendment. The vote passed 74–15, making Arkansas the twelfth state to ratify the Nineteenth Amendment. Women filled the Arkansas Capitol carrying yellow banners reading, “Votes for Women.” The Nineteenth Amendment became law on August 26, 1920.

As a result of the Nineteenth Amendment, Arkansas witnessed the transformation of the AESCC to the Arkansas League of Women Voters (ALWV), with Florence Brown Cotnam president. The ALWV created citizenship schools to inform the new voters on the responsibilities of government and their voting rights. The league continued to work for legislation giving additional rights to women.

By Paula Kyzer Taylor, Arkansas History Commission
Encyclopedia of Arkansas History & Culture. Central Arkansas Library System, Little Rock, AR. Last Updated 8/20/2020.
https://encyclopediaofarkansas.net/entries/womens-suffrage-movement-4252/

[Permission to reproduce the article above has been granted.]

3. State Suffragists

3. State Suffragists

Mary Burt Brooks

Hattie Wyatt Caraway, unknown city, widow of Arkansas senator, became the first women elected to the U.S. Senate after women’s suffrage

Florence Brown Cotnam, Little Rock, persuasive orator, vice-president of Arkansas Woman Suffrage Association, reorganized it into the Arkansas Equal Suffrage Central Committee which worked with political parties, addressed state legislature

Catherine “Kate” Campbell Cunningham

Alice Ellington (Missouri), president of Political Equality League, secretary of the Southern States Women’s Suffrage Association, member of the Arkansas Flying Squadron, went to New York City to help organize for women’s suffrage in 1915

Mary Fletcher

Eliza (“Lizzie”) A. Dorman Fyler, Eureka Springs, formed first Arkansas Woman Suffrage Association in 1881

Miles Ledford Langley, Arkadelphia, proposed suffrage plank in 1868

Clara McDiarmid, Little Rock, led Arkansas Woman Suffrage Association

Minnie Rutherford

Adolphine Fletcher Terry

Gertrude Watkins, unknown city, officer with the Little Rock Political Equality League, Went to New York City as a member of the Arkansas Flying Squadron to organize in 1915

4. Additional Resources

4. Additional Resources

Books

Arkansas Women and the Right to Vote: The Little Rock Campaigns: 1868-1920 by Bernadette Cahill, Butler Center Books, 2015

The Woman Suffrage Movement in Arkansas by A. Elizabeth Taylor, 1957

Notable Women of Arkansas: From Hattie to Hillary, 100 Names to Know by Nancy Hendricks, 2016

Behold, Our Works Were Good: A Handbook of Arkansas Women’s History ed. by Elizabeth Jacoway, 1988

Articles

“Stepping outside the Bounds of Convention: Adolphine Fletcher Terry and Radical Suffragism in Little Rock, 1911–1920” by Bernadette Cahill, Pulaski County Historical Review 60 (Winter 2012): 122–129

“‘Young people think women always had the right to vote’: Josephine Miller and the Arkansas Woman Suffrage Campaign.” by Bernadette Cahill, Pulaski County Historical Review 61 (Spring 2013): 11–15

“Political Animal: Florence Brown Cotnam and the Arkansas Women’s Suffrage Movement” by Jared B. Craig, MA thesis, University of Arkansas at Little Rock, 2017

“‘They Made Their Voices Heard!’ The Last Drive of the Women’s Suffrage Movement in Arkansas” by Calee M. Henderson, MA thesis, University of Arkansas at Little Rock, 2014

“So Close, yet So Far” by Jack Schnedler, Arkansas Democrat-Gazette, November 5, 2018, pp. 1D, 6D
“The Woman Suffrage Movement in Arkansas” by Antoinette Elizabeth Taylor, Arkansas Historical Quarterly 15 (Spring 1956): 17–52

“From the Parlour to the Polls: Arkansas and the Women’s Suffrage Question” by Kristen L. Thompson, MA thesis, University of Arkansas, 2003

Whayne, Jeannie M. “World War I and Woman’s Suffrage in Arkansas.” In The War at Home: Perspectives on the Arkansas Experience during World War I, edited by Mark K. Christ. Fayetteville: University Press of Arkansas, 2020

Exhibit

Arkansas Women’s Suffrage Centennial Project Virtual Exhibit. University of Arkansas at Little Rock Center for Arkansas History and Culture. http://ualrexhibits.org/suffrage/

Home » State Campaigns » Arkansas