Arizona

1. Summary
Voters in Arizona passed women’s suffrage in 1912. The legislature ratified the 19th Amendment on February 12, 1920. Acknowledgement.
2a. State Suffrage History
Women’s Suffrage
Arizona State Library
As early as 1848, activists like Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony began fighting for a woman’s right to vote in the United States. This struggle came to Tucson, Arizona with Frances Willard who at the time was the president of the Women’s Christian Temperance Union. Activists successfully introduced bills “to Extend the Right of Suffrage to Women” in 1881, 1883, and 1885 but the Territorial Legislature defeated them each time.
As Arizona began its bid for statehood in 1891 the issue of women’s suffrage was again discussed, this time during the first Arizona Constitutional Convention. The problem was raised by Josephine Hughes, Frances Munds, Mary J. R. West, and Mable Ann Hakes. Unfortunately, statehood, and as result suffrage, was denied by President Benjamin Harrison. Arizona would not be allowed to pursue statehood again for 10 years. In the meantime, aspiring voters formed the Arizona Suffrage Association with future senator Frances Willard Munds as secretary.
In 1903, it seemed that the work of these suffragettes would finally find success when a Suffrage Bill was passed by both houses of the Arizona Legislature. Despite its success, Governor Alexander Brodie vetoed the bill citing constitutional issues.
The Second Arizona Constitutional Convention in 1910 provided another opportunity. The National Women’s Suffrage Association sent representatives and money to Arizona to encourage the writing of women’s suffrage into the state constitution. This time Governor Brodie objected because he thought it would jeopardize the bid for statehood with President William Taft.
Eventually, Arizona became a state on February 14, 1912, and activists were prepared to ask voters to decide the fate of women voters. The initiative qualified for the ballot on July 5, 1912. By November of that same year, voters (all men) overwhelmingly approved women’s suffrage, and Arizona joined nine other states and territories: Territory of Wyoming (1869), Territory of Utah (1870), Territory of Washington (1883), Territory of Montana (1887), Colorado (1890), Idaho (1896), California (1911), Oregon (1912), and Kansas (1912). It would be another eight years until the 19th Amendment to the Constitution, “the right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of sex,” would pass on August 26, 1920.
Arizona State Library, Archives & Records
https://azlibrary.gov/dazl/learners/research-topics/womens-suffrage
[Permission to reproduce the article above has been granted.]
2b. State Suffrage History
Arizona and the 19th Amendment
National Park Service
Arizona became a territory of the US in 1863 and was not a state during the early days of discussions about a federal amendment enfranchising women. Suffragists in the Arizona territory worked to build support for women’s right to vote and lobby the territorial government. They were successful in getting woman suffrage bills introduced several times in the 1880s, but each was defeated in the legislature. Josephine Brawley Hughes created the first women’s suffrage organization in 1891 as the push for Arizona statehood began. She was joined by other women such as Frances Willard Munds. Hughes, Munds, and other suffragists campaigned for women’s right to vote to be included in the new state constitution. President Benjamin Harrison rejected Arizona’s bid for statehood and the constitutional protection of woman suffrage was no longer available.
Munds eventually became the leader of the Arizona Suffrage Association in the early 1900s. She reached out to Mormon women in the territory – something other groups refused to do. Mormons were often discriminated against due to their religion. But Munds recognized the importance of Mormon women in the fight for suffrage.
They came close to success when the territorial legislature passed a suffrage bill in 1903, but Governor Alexander Brodie vetoed it. Brodie also objected to the idea of including women as eligible voters in a proposed state constitution, fearing that including suffrage would hurt Arizona’s chance for statehood.
Arizona became a state on February 14, 1912. Suffragists pushed for a woman suffrage initiative to be put to the voters right away. In November 1912, the Arizona male electorate voted overwhelmingly in favor of enfranchising women. Arizona was the tenth state in which women won full voting rights.
After decades of arguments for and against women’s suffrage, the US Congress finally approved the 19th Amendment in June 1919. After Congress passed the 19th Amendment, at least 36 states needed to vote in favor of it for it to become law. This process is called ratification.
On February 12, 1920, Arizona voted to ratify the 19th Amendment. By August of 1920, 36 states (including Arizona) ratified the amendment, ensuring that the right to vote could not be denied based on sex.
Arizona and the 19th Amendment, National Park Service
https://www.nps.gov/articles/arizona-and-the-19th-amendment.htm
[Courtesy of the National Park Service]
3. State Suffragists
W. B. Cleary
Laura Gregg, unknown city, NAWSA organizer, helped set up suffrage clubs
Maie Heard, Phoenix, activist, died 1951 and is buried in Memory Lawn Mort. and Cemetery
Josephine Brawley Hughes, Tucson, died March 1926 and is buried in Evergreen Memorial Park, Tucson
Frances W. Munds, Prescott, led the small but effective Arizona suffrage organization, died in 1948 and is buried in Mt.View Cemetery, Prescott
Pauline O’Neill, Prescott, died in 1961 and is buried in Las Angeles Calvary Cemetery, Las Angeles, CA
Jennie Tritle, Prescott, died in 1925 and is buried in Bellefontaine Cemetery, St. Louis, Missouri
4. Additional Resources
Books
Winning Their Place: Arizona Women in Politics, 1883-1950 by Heidi J. Osselaer, 2009
Levis & Lace: Arizona Women Who Made History by Jan Cleere, 2011
De-sexing the Ballot Box: The History of Woman Suffrage in Arizona, 1883-1912 by Thomas Lauerman, 1973
More than Petticoats: Remarkable Arizona Women by Wynne Brown, 2003
De-Sexing the Ballot Box: The History of Woman Suffrage in Arizona, 1883-1912 by Thomas Lauerman, Master’s thesis, Arizona State University, 1973
Los Tucsonenses: The Mexican Community in Tucson, 1854-1941 by Thomas E. Sheridan, University of Arizona Press, 1992
Articles
“From Sidelines to Center Stage: Women and Arizona’s Quest for Statehood” by Heidi Osselaer, Territorial Times (November 2011)
“Arizona Women argue for the vote” by Amy DeHaan, Journal of Arizona History (p. 375-394), 2004
“American View of Mexican Women, 1820-1890” by Kathleen M. Garcia, Arizona History Convention Paper, 1998.
Websites
Arizona Suffrage, Window On Your Past
http://windowonyourpast.com/site/research/arizona-suffrage/
Arizona Women’s Heritage Trail, http://www.womensheritagetrail.org/
