Expanded Station 11

11     THE SUFFRAGE CAMPAIGN IN WARTIME, 1917

‘‘Kaiser Wilson, have you forgotten your sympathy with the poor Germans because they were not self-governed? 20,000,000 American women are not self-governed.’’
From a National Woman’s Party banner carried by White House pickets

NATIONAL AMERICAN WOMAN SUFFRAGE ASSOCIATION’S CAMPAIGN HALTED DURING THE WAR

Mindful of the great loss of momentum from the woman suffrage campaign pause during the Civil War, NAWSA and the National Woman’s Party continued to campaign for the amendment but in very different ways.

As it was becoming clear that the US was heading for entrance into the Great War, Carrie Chapman Catt knew that any distraction from the war effort would be “considered almost treasonable.”[1] She was a pacifist and was concerned about the reaction of the International Woman Suffrage Alliance if she and NAWSA supported the war, so kept a low profile at first.[2] But ultimately she decided to put aside her personal beliefs and with concurrence of NAWSA’s Executive Council of One Hundred led NAWSA’s public support for the war, believing that in the end it would benefit the cause.

After the US entered the war in April 2017, former NAWSA president Anna Howard Shaw became a driving force in mobilizing American women for the war effort. Shaw headed the Woman’s Committee of the Council of National Defense, a national organization meant to harness the energy of the millions of women who wanted to serve their country in time of war.  It matched women with the specific need.[3]

Departments were set up within NAWSA, each  focused on a different aspect of war support–such as thrift, food production, and conservation. State and local NAWSA affiliates were expected to take on war support activities in addition to quietly continuing their suffrage efforts as much as possible. The federal government, in preparation for war, urged men to join the military and women to take clerical jobs and work in factories making war machinery to replace the men.  Women were also urged to engage in thrift, food production, and making medical supplies, such as bandages, for the war effort. Many women also went into military service.[4]

One historian observed, “Suffragists were at war, many suffragists were cooperating with Wilson in hopes of securing his support for suffrage while other suffragists were being imprisoned and brutally treated for protesting Wilson’s reluctance to extend women the vote. Both the moderate suffragists and the militant suffragists were exerting pressure upon Wilson, and millions of American women were demonstrating, through service and sacrifice, their claim to full citizenship.”[5] 

When Wilson finally changed his position and supported the suffrage amendment, he said it was because the country needed the support of women to win the war. He was stronger in his statement to Congress on September 30, 1918, shortly before the final end of the war on November 11, 2018: “We have made partners of the women in this war…Shall we admit them only to a partnership of suffering and sacrifice and toil and not to a partnership of privilege?”[6]

When the US entered the war, members of Congress informally agreed not to allow other matters to distract them from the war[7] However, suffragists did not stop their efforts although NAWSA kept theirs very low key.  Keeping a promise Senator Andrieus Aristieus Jones of New Mexico had made to NAWSA lobbyist Maud Wood Park before the US’s entrance into the war, the Senate Woman Suffrage Committee held four hearings, with NAWSA, NWP, National Association Opposed to Woman Suffrage, and one with Progressives, Socialists, and Prohibitionists who supported woman suffrage.[8]  In September 1917, thanks largely to effort of Jeanette Rankin, the first women elected to Congress, some measurable progress was made.  The House of Representatives created its Woman Suffrage Committee with Representative John Edward Raker, Democrat of California as its chairman.[9] Because this was an administrative action not a legislative action, it did not violate the agreement about legislative distraction during the war.[10]

NATIONAL WOMAN’S PARTY BANNERS EXPOSED PRESIDENT WILSON’S HYPOCRISY

Women picketing in front of the White House with a banner that states "To the Russian Envoys" at the top, the rest is unintelligible.
Using provocative banners to embarrass the president, the pickets were attacked by government workers and military men while demonstrating.

In contrast to NAWSA, the NWP kept its focus on a constitutional amendment to win the vote despite the US entry into World War I. The NWP continued picketing the White House despite public outcry against the controversial tactics. The NWP saw that controversy was useful for gaining media coverage, good or bad, and continued the protests at the White House, using the rhetoric of war for their righteous cause. Their pickets would endure ridicule and physical attacks by mobs that included servicemen, and arrests by police resulted in prison terms of 30-60 days. Some members of the military and the public repeatedly attacked the White House pickets, while police did nothing to protect the demonstrators. New and audacious banners invited publicity and arrest, calling President Wilson a hypocrite for trying to “make the world safe for democracy” in Europe while denying women democracy at home.

SUFFRAGE PICKETS WERE ARRESTED

By late June 1917, the NWP’s incendiary banners prompted the Wilson administration to arrest the “Silent Sentinel” pickets. They were given increasingly harsh sentences in the District of Columbia Jail and the Occoquan Workhouse (part of the D.C. prison system in Lorton, Virginia). Most of the women were arrested on the trumped-up charge of “obstructing traffic.”

Suffragists held their lettered banners about the war stating that women in this country should be free before our men fight for freedom in Europe. When the banner addressed to Elihu Root, envoy to Russia where women could vote appeared, a huge crowd gathered.[11]

A woman picking with a banner that reads "Kaiser Wilson" at the top
This “Kaiser Wilson” banner is
another example of the explosive banners used by the NWP to protest President Wilson’s lack of support for woman suffrage.

On August 14, 1917, Catherine Flanagan carried the banner referring to the president as “Kaiser Wilson.” Another huge crowd gathered and became violent. As the crowd tore banners from them, suffragists marched back to Cameron House.  Reinforcements with fresh tricolor banners marched out of Cameron House, but the huge crowd blocking the street and filling Lafayette Park, attacked the suffragists en route. Led by a yeoman in uniform, the mob tore away the banners and destroyed them. 

A police matron, observed by two men (possibly policemen), in the act of arresting suffragists holding banners and wearing sashes over their white dresses.
A police matron (center) arrested suffrage pickets Catherine Flanagan and Madeleine Watson outside the White House on August 17, 1917. The women, charged with “obstructing traffic,” were sentenced to 30 days in the Occoquan Workhouse in Lorton, Virginia.

The yeoman climbed a ladder to the second floor of Cameron House and tore down the tricolor that hung there.  Another person in the mob climbed up the other side of the balcony, and tore down the American flag. With doors locked, suffragists Virginia Arnold and Lucy Burns stood steadfast on the balcony over the front door holding the “Kaiser Wilson” and the tricolor banners.  Others joined them. Suddenly a shot was fired from the crowd. The bullet went through a window and lodged into the ceiling, above the spot where two other suffragists, Ella Morton Dean and Georgiana Sturgess, were standing.  The shooter was suspected to be the same yeoman who had led the mob and climbed to the second floor. [12]  Then three more yeomen climbed up and onto the balcony grabbing the banners.  The suffragists fought to keep them. One yeoman struck Sturgess and took her banner.[13]

Meanwhile two suffragists went out the back door with a fresh “Kaiser Wilson” banner, marched to the sidewalk in front of the White House and took up their station.  Shortly, the same yeoman leader saw them, grabbed their banner, and dragged them along the sidewalk before destroying the banner.  The police standing there did nothing to protect the suffragists.[14]

Later that day, the mob attacked again.  Someone in the crowd knocked down Madeleine Watson and kicked her.  Watson had to be carried into Cameron House.  That evening men tried to climb over the back garden fence.  The suffragists did not sleep that night.[15]

The next day was only slightly less violent.  The suffragists marched to the White House with their banners and were attacked by servicemen and boys.  The police did nothing. Suffragists were struck down, and banners destroyed.  Alice Paul was dragged along the sidewalk.[16] Although public mobs violently attacked the suffragists continually, they were never charged. The suffragists were not deterred.


[1] Jacqueline Van Voris, Carrie Chapman Catt, A public Life (New York: The Feminist Press, City University of New York City, 1987), 136.

[2] Ibid, 137.

[3] https://www.nps.gov/articles/women-in-world-war-i.htm, accessed on 4/30/2021.

[4] Ibid.

[5] Ibid.

[6] ibid

[7] Maud Wood Park, Front Door Lobby, ed., Edna Lamprey Stantial (Boston, MA: Beacon Press, 1960), 72.

[8]Ibid, 79-84.

[9] The House Supports Women’s Suffrage, 1917–1919 | US House of Representatives: History, Art & Archives, accessed on 7/15/2021.

[10] Maud Wood Park, Front Door Lobby, ed. Edna Lamprey Stantial (Boston, MA: Beacon Press, 1960), 87.

[11] Inez Haynes Irwin, The Story of the Woman’s Party (New York: Harcourt, Brace and Company, 1921), 230.

[12] Ibid, 230-231.

[13] Ibid

[14] Ibid, 231.

[15] Ibid, 232.

[16] Ibid.

Home » Expanded 19 Informational Stations » Expanded Station 11